What if? The Effects of a Hard Decoupling from China on the German Economy with David Baqaee, Benjamin Moll, Moritz Schularick, Feodora Teti, Joschka Wanner and Sihwan Yang. in "Paris Report 2: Europe's Economic Security", Jean Pisani-Ferry, Beatrice Weder di Mauro, and Jeromin Zettelmeyer (eds), CEPR Press, Paris & London. May 2024.
Cold turkey decoupling vs. gradual decoupling vs. gradual de-risking.
How would the German economy cope with a hard economic decoupling from China? We study a scenario where the global economy fragments into three distinct blocs: the G7 economies and their allies, China and her allies, as well as neutral countries. German trade with China would have to be entirely rerouted to countries within the “Western” block and neutral countries. We quantify the costs of such a worst-case hard decoupling using the Baqaee and Farhi (2021) multi-sector model of the world economy. Our key finding is that a total cut-off of trade relations with China would have severe but not devastating effects on the German economy. The welfare loss for Germany (relative to a no-cut-off baseline) would be around 5% of Gross National Expenditure (GNE) over the first few months and around 4% over the first year, plus additional short run costs due to business-cycle amplification effects. In the medium and long run, the costs would fall to a permanent loss in the 1-2% range. Less extreme decoupling or gradual de-risking scenarios (“small yard, high fence”) would incur smaller costs. The single most influential assumption relates to the “trade elasticity,” i.e., the ease and speed with which trade can be reorganized away from China to neutral countries and within the “Western” block. Our findings, in particular the critical dependence of economic costs on the time horizon over which adjustments take place, provide some rationale for embarking on a gradual de-risking trajectory to avoid a costly and politically contentious hard decoupling dictated by geopolitical events.
Links & Downloads
Earlier versions
Media coverage
- Politico: Why Germany’s Scholz is bowing to the Chinese dragon
- Euractiv: Eurozone finance chiefs fear trade jitters could get in the way of EU competitiveness plans
- The Economist: Europe’s economy is under attack from all sides
- Tagesspiegel: Analyse: Abkopplung von China vergleichbar mit Coronakrise
- Münchner Merkur: „Kalter Krieg 2.0“: Abkopplung von China wäre für Deutschland „schwerer Schock“ – aber machbar
- Der Spiegel: Abbruch der Wirtschaftsbeziehungen zu China wäre wohl verkraftbar
- Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung: Abkoppelung von China wäre Schock für Wirtschaft wie Finanzkrise
- Business Insider: Risiko China: So teuer wäre eine Abkopplung für Deutschland, und so ließen sich Kosten kleinhalten, laut einer neuen Studie des IfW
- Die Welt: "Das kostet bis zu fünf Prozent unserer Wirtschaftsleistung"
- n-tv: Studie: Abkopplung von China wäre für Deutschland wirtschaftlicher Schock
Last updated on November 15, 2024. © Julian Hinz 1987–2024.